Just like with copy paper, there’s no shortage of sketchbook options out there — prices range from just a few euros to thirty-something. Personally, my pain threshold is around 15 euros. I try to buy my sketchbooks from the same stores where I get my fineliners, if possible, which naturally limits the selection I’m reviewing here.
If you’re not into heavy sketching or drawing, just go with the cheapest (white) paper you can find — honestly, it won’t make much of a difference. But if you want to bet on a safe choice, maybe these few alternatives can help you out.
Molotow – Blackbook Graffiti Sketching
Product info: Shop.Molotow.com
Basic blackbook with a really good price/quality ratio. Paper weight is 90 g/m² — the thinnest among the ones listed, but still pretty decent. Doesn’t pale in comparison to older MTN sketchbooks, Stylefiles, and so on. Manufactured by Clairefontaine (a French company), though the label says they’re actually made in Morocco. Available in A4 and A5.
These are very well available. I buy mine from Geezers/Molotow Finland, Helsinki (FI).
Molotow – Professional Sketchbook
Product info: Shop.Molotow.Com
205 g/m². By far the best — and the most expensive. I’ve only used one, and that’s because I got it for free somewhere. The paper is so thick and coated that no markers bleed through. Also suitable for acrylics, watercolors, and similar media. Comes in few different sizes as well as “basic” pads instead of books. If you wanna try these, they’re also very well available.
Ironlak
Product info: Ironlak.com
A relatively good, nothing-to-complain-about sketchbook from Ironlak. Not sure where these are manufactured — my guess is China. Comes with an elastic band to keep it closed and has a ribbon bookmark. 120 g/m² acid-free paper, 192 pages. Available in few different sizes/formats.
I don’t remember where I got mine, as these aren’t available in Finland or nearby. Must’ve been somewhere online.
MTN BlackBook – Older Version
No longer in stock. Features an engraved “Montana” text instead of “MTN.” Probably 90 g/m² paper. Hard cover with a subtle square-textured surface.
Good, very smooth (almost shiny) paper. Feels nice to draw on. Similar to the Stylefile or Montana (Germany) sketchbooks.
MTN BlackBook – Current Version
Product info: MontanaColors.com
A good one. 110 g/m² acid-free paper. Slightly less shiny and smooth than the older version, but overall just as good. Comes with an elastic band to keep it closed. The cover has a leather-like, even-textured surface.
The only downside is the cover’s softness. While it feels great in hand and is thicker than many others, it’s not hard — so the paper tends to bend slightly once you’ve used more than half the pages, since there’s less support underneath. Other than that, it’s top-notch quality. And well available too. I bought mine from Make Your Mark, Helsinki (FI).
Montana
Product info: Montana-Cans.com
A solid sketchbook from Montana Cans. 120 g/m² paper. Since the paper is on the thicker side, it handles alcohol-based markers well. Most importantly, it offers high quality at a good price. Contains 144 pages / 82 sheets. The format I’ve used is A5 landscape (21 cm × 14.8 cm). Hardcover with an embossed Montana Colors logo on the front. Pretty much identical with the Stylefile’s sketchbooks. Good availability. If/when I need these, I usually buy them from Unckan Store, Helsinki (FI).
Stylefile
Product info: Unfade.de
Another solid, nothing-to-complain-about sketchbook from Stylefile. 120 g/m² paper, slightly thicker and therefore great for alcohol-based markers. Most importantly, it delivers high quality at a low price. Sounds like ad speak, but this one actually lives up to the promise. Contains 144 pages / 82 sheets in A5 landscape format (21 cm × 14.8 cm). Solid hardcover with a discreetly embossed Stylefile logo. Available also in size A4.
If I understood correctly, these are not made anymore. Which is a shame, since these were superior in price/quality ratio. In plain English: the cheapest one. I used to buy these from Make Your Mark, Helsinki (FI).
If you by any chance want to see if there’s more variety in sketchbooks (there is!), you can check out these listings from Penstore or Amazon. As said, sky’s the limit on this.